Our Magnificence Editor’s Trustworthy Opinion on the NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

Some merchandise present up in every single place — subway advertisements, Instagram, celeb endorsements. With this collection, we’re testing such merchandise to conclude one factor: Does it stay as much as the hype?

What’s everybody speaking about?

This reasonably priced eyeliner guarantees to outline the eyes with extremely pigmented colour, just like liquid eyeliner, however in an easy-to-use pencil format, ultimate for inexperienced persons and novices alike. It guarantees to final by way of warmth and humidity, and eliminates the necessity for a pencil sharpener since you may simply twist up for extra merchandise.

What’s the thrill about?

With a $6 price ticket, it is no marvel Amazon consumers and wonder YouTubers cannot get sufficient of the NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil. This low-cost magnificence product has climbed to the highest of Amazon’s magnificence part and shortly grew to become a bestseller. It additionally earned hundreds of rave evaluations throughout Ulta, Goal, and YouTube. Given its low value, you may reward just a few to family members and deal with your self to a pleasant magnificence reward.

The place’s all of the hype coming from?

  • This widespread eyeliner earned a 4.5-star common score from over 97,800 glowing Amazon evaluations.
  • Magnificence YouTubers are obsessed with the creamy and blendable system of this eyeliner. Make-up tutorials and evaluations obtained tons of of hundreds of YouTube views.
  • Years of protection on websites, like ELLE, Harper’s BAZAAR, and Attract.

So does it stay as much as the hype?

Key Specs

NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

Now 11% Off

  • Score: 4.5-star common score from greater than 97,800 Amazon evaluations
  • The place to purchase: Amazon, Ulta, NYX, and Goal
  • Colours obtainable: 13
  • What reviewers are saying: “That is one of the best eyeliner ever! I apply it to my waterline to brighten up my eyes. These things lasts actually all day! Like 12+ hours. I used to be cautious of it because it’s a mechanical pencil, however I’m so impressed. I’d undoubtedly suggest this, and I’d purchase it once more,” says one 5-star Amazon overview.
  • What I feel: As Greatest Merchandise’ magnificence editor, a part of my job consists of testing new magnificence merchandise and classics alike, to make sure that all magnificence merchandise featured on our web site are 100% value your hard-earned cash and are implausible magnificence items. Nicely, the NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is a stable pencil eyeliner that does not outperform higher-end choices, nevertheless it undoubtedly provides them a run for his or her cash. And given its $6 price ticket, I actually cannot complain about one small factor I might change.
the eyeliner pencils on the table showing the tip of the pencil and the colors

Nicole Saunders

How’d we come to this conclusion?

There are a number of explanation why I get pleasure from utilizing the NYX Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil, together with:

The twist-up applicator

I can not inform you what number of occasions I’ve forgotten to pack an eyeliner sharpener earlier than a visit and needed to rush order the $1 moist n wild sharpener off Amazon. The NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is a twist-up pencil that does not require a sharpener. Given the design, solely a bit of the product comes out at a time, which is nice as a result of it helps forestall your giftee from twisting up an excessive amount of eyeliner, inflicting it to interrupt off.

It does not tug on the eyes

In contrast to dry picket pencil eyeliners, the slim NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil has a very creamy system that glides simply throughout my eyelids. It does not pull or tug on the delicate eye space, which is at all times a win in my magnificence e-book. Given its formulation, your giftee has just a few seconds to smudge the eyeliner for a smoldering smokey eye impact, however as soon as it units, the eyeliner locks in place. I usually want a crisp cat eye, so this is not an issue for my day by day put on, however I might see this probably changing into a slight annoyance for others who like a smokey look. My recommendation: Incorporate the Sigma Magnificence E30 pencil brush to hurry up the smudging of the eyeliner.

Accessible shades

There are 13 gift-worthy shades, together with Brown, Bronze, and White. Movie star make-up artist Jamie Greenberg lately informed our buddies at ELLE the white shade is unbelievable for lining the waterline for a brightening impact. There are additionally enjoyable jewel tones, comparable to Aqua Inexperienced, Gold, and two shades of purple. Black eyeliner is my no-fail eyeliner colour, particularly when creating winged eyeliner, and I gotta say, NYX actually makes a real panther black eyeliner, particularly for the worth! The pigmentation is really subsequent degree, and the colour payoff jogs my memory of the pricier choices I’ve examined prior to now.

nicole swatching the three colors of eyeliner she has onto the backside of her hand

Nicole Saunders

The wearability

All through my month-long testing course of, I wore this eyeliner to the workplace, round my condominium, out with buddies, and located the NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil lasts from AM to PM. Most eyeliners smudge on me after I do not use an eyeshadow primer, like my trusty Too Confronted Shadow Insurance coverage, however this one holds up properly with out the primer.

It is also vital to notice that I put on eyeliner on my eyelid since I am not an enormous fan of how I look with eyeliner on my waterline. For this story, I did check the way it carried out on my waterline as a result of I wish to guarantee what I like to recommend is at all times on level for readers. In my expertise, the creamy system was non-irritating and lasted roughly 4 hours earlier than it began to fade. Whereas waterline longevity will not be a deal breaker for me, it is one thing value contemplating in case your bestie loves sporting waterline eyeliner. Given its slim measurement, the NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is one thing they will throw into their Barbiecore clutch and contact up earlier than heading out to after-work drinks.

What’s the underside line?

The NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil is creamy and has a clean consistency that applies like a dream. Given its low-cost value level, I used to be impressed it carried out in addition to it did, and I really feel assured recommending it to anybody who searching for an reasonably priced eyeliner. It has a slim design that makes it simple to create detailed graphic eye moments or tight line and line the waterline. These eyeliners are additionally highly-pigmented, actually reminding me of higher-end merchandise you’ll find at Sephora. Since this eyeliner is barely $6, you need to reward your self and your beauty-loving family and friends these high-performance eyeliners.

Store NYX Skilled Make-up Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

Store Our Different Favourite Eyeliners

Low cost Thrills

Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Waterproof Eyeliner
moist n wild Breakup Proof Retractable Gel Waterproof Eyeliner

Now 38% Off


No Budge Retractable Eyeliner
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner

Now 20% Off

Wealthy Pigment

TattooStudio Gel Eyeliner Pencil
Maybelline New York TattooStudio Gel Eyeliner Pencil

Now 30% Off

AAPI- and LGBT-Owned

Point Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil
ONE/SIZE by Patrick Starrr Level Made 24-Hour Gel Eyeliner Pencil
Headshot of Nicole Saunders

Magnificence Editor

Nicole Saunders is the Magnificence Editor at BestProducts.com, the place she oversees protection on all issues magnificence. When she’s not creating buying guides, interviewing specialists, and testing magnificence remedies, you may in all probability discover her strolling round Decrease Manhattan or overanalyzing the most recent episode of “Succession.” You may ship all lipstick and calamari suggestions to her inbox and DM her memes on Instagram.